Norman Serves on National Science Foundation Review Panel
March 30th, 2017 by Gwen Green
ASBTDC’s innovation consultant, Rebecca Norman, was on the other side of the SBIR/STTR proposal review process for the first time last month.
In her role as the center’s innovation consultant, Norman helps Arkansas entrepreneurs and companies develop Small Business Innovation Research and Small Business Technology Transfer federal funding proposals. March 16, she served on a National Science Foundation SBIR/STTR Phase I review panel in Arlington, Va.
Dr. Anna Brady-Estevez, the agency’s SBIR/STTR program manager, invited her to participate.
The experience gave Norman “an enhanced understanding of the key considerations that are weighed during proposal evaluation and how the panelists converse with each other to arrive at a consensus,” she said.
Norman’s panel focused on the research topic “Environmental Sensing, Monitoring, and Modeling.” They considered the technical and commercial strengths and weaknesses of 14 proposals and suggested rankings for funding consideration, while also giving all applicants meaningful feedback.
Each panelist served as lead reviewer and scribe for three proposals, reviewing and ranking others prior to the session.
Even proposals with great commercial potential also need to be technically strong, Norman observed. “Although preliminary data is not required for NSF SBIR/STTR proposals, most reviewers do want to see that there is sound technical backing for a proposed approach and that applicants have considered the full range of factors that technologies would be exposed to in a real-world environment,” she said.
Norman enjoyed her first turn as a commercial reviewer and hopes for additional review panel opportunities with NSF or other agencies. “It was a great learning experience that I can use to benefit future Arkansas SBIR/STTR applicants.”